Behaviorism and Mental Health

Alternative perspective on psychiatry's so-called mental disorders | PHILIP HICKEY, PH.D.

  • Home
  • About
  • Contact
  • Tell Your Story
  • Submit Your Story
  • Moderation Policy

A Compelling Critique of Psychiatric ‘Diagnosis’

December 30, 2013 By Phil Hickey | 4 Comments

fb-share-icon
Visit Us
Follow Me
Tweet

I have just read a very interesting and insightful article on this topic.  It’s called After DSM-5: A Critical Mental Health Research Agenda for the 21st Century.  It was written by Jeffrey Lacasse, PhD, and is a guest editorial published in Research on Social Work Practice.

Here are some quotes:

“At times, it has seemed that the APA has behaved very much like a corporation seeking profit and influence rather than a scientific organization charged with the crucially important task of defining mental disorders.”

[DSM-5]”… is vague and provides no clarity regarding the boundaries between what is normal and what is mentally disordered.”

“All problems defined in the DSM-5, from adjustment disorder to sexual problems to shyness, are just claimed to be medical…”

“The DSM-IV-TR mentions that brain changes in schizophrenia may be related to treatment with antipsychotic medication and notes that antidepressants may cause akathisia (a dangerous adverse effect associated with suicidal behavior…).   Despite the increasing body of literature demonstrating the clinical importance of these issues…references to both were deleted from DSM-5.”

“The DSM-5 field trial data demonstrate that DSM-5 categories are unreliable…a crucially important issue that should be addressed in both research and practice.”

“Thus the unreliability of psychiatric diagnosis can confound both the defining of client problems and the application of research evidence to clients.”

“…they sometimes explain that depression is caused by serotonin deficiency…  Clients are likely to absorb such messages as scientific facts…This should disturb those who think clinical practice and informed consent should be based on evidence, as serotonin deficiency as a cause of depression is known to be a myth…”

“Using the language of ‘mental disorder’ and presumed underlying brain disease or defect could have important effects on how clients view their problems and negatively impact their capacity to recover from them…”

Dr. Lacasse’s article is cogent and articulate, and cites a great many references.  It draws together succinctly, yet thoroughly, many of the critical issues in the present debate.

It has long been my position that psychiatry is scientifically empty and morally bankrupt.  It is time for the other helping professions to disassociate themselves from psychiatry and its spurious, money-driven “nosology,” and to develop their own person-centered conceptual framework for the services they provide.

It has also been my belief that social workers are ideally poised to provide a leadership role in developments of this sort.

Dr. Lacasse is by no means the first social worker to critique psychiatry, but his paper draws together many of the critical threads of this debate, and would serve as an excellent springboard from which the social work profession could re-appraise their ties to psychiatry.

Thanks to Mad in America for the link to Dr. Lacasse’s paper.

fb-share-icon
Visit Us
Follow Me
Tweet

Filed Under: A Behavioral Approach to Mental Disorders Tagged With: critique of psychiatric 'diagnosis', DSM-5

About Phil Hickey

I am a licensed psychologist, presently retired. I have worked in clinical and managerial positions in the mental health, corrections, and addictions fields in the United States and England. My wife Nancy and I have been married since 1970 and have four grown children.

 

fb-share-icon
Visit Us
Follow Me
Tweet

Recent Articles

  • Dr. Pies and The Chemical Imbalance Deception
  • Don’t Believe Everything You Read: Words Matter Desperately
  • Is Anti-Psychiatry Harmful?
  • Celebrating the Anti-Psychiatry Movement
  • Dr. Pies:  Still Going Wrong
  • A Psychiatrist Critiques Psychiatry, And Does A Great Job!
  • Dr. Aftab Interviews Dr. Pies
  • Is Psychiatry Dangerous?
  • Deep Sleep “Therapy” in Australia in the 1960’s and 70’s. Could Something Like This Happen Today?
  • Drs. Pies and Ruffalo Still Rattling Their Wooden Swords

The phrase "mental health" as used in the name of this website is simply a term of convenience. It specifically does not imply that the human problems embraced by this term are illnesses, or that their absence constitutes health. Indeed, the fundamental tenet of this site is that there are no mental illnesses, and that conceptualizing human problems in this way is spurious, destructive, disempowering, and stigmatizing.

Disclaimer

The purpose of this website is to provide a forum where current practices and ideas in the mental health field can be critically examined and discussed. It is not possible in this kind of context to provide psychological help or advice to individuals who may read this site, and nothing written here should be construed in this manner. Readers seeking psychological help should consult a qualified practitioner in their own local area. They should explain their concerns to this person and develop a trusting working relationship. It is only in a one-to-one relationship of this kind that specific advice should be given or taken.

Privacy Policy

Recent Comments

Popular Topics…

abuse ADHD akathisia alcohol alcohol/drugs antidepressants antipsychotics anxiety benzodiazepines bipolar books worth reading case study chemical imbalance theory conflict of interest dealing with problems of daily living dependence depression drug DSM DSM-5 ECT expansion of psychiatric turf IF THEY'RE NOT ILLNESSES WHAT ARE THEY? involuntary commitment Mad in America major tranquilizers myth of chemical imbalance myth of mental illness neuroleptics over-medicalization of everyday life parenting pharmaceutical industry placebo posttraumatic stress disorder Psychiatric "spin" research corruption schizophrenia shock "treatment" side effects somatic symptom disorder SSRI's suicide survivors of psychiatry violence war on drugs

© 2009–2021